Oaxaca Old Fashioned: the mezcal classic from Death & Co
Phil Ward created this cocktail in 2007 at one of New York's most famous bars. Reposado tequila and LÆPOCA Mezcal Espadín come together at a ratio of 3 to 1, with agave syrup and Angostura bitters. It is hard to get more complexity out of four ingredients. The drink that kicked off the worldwide mezcal boom.
2 minPrep time
1/3Difficulty
TumblerGlass
2007Created
Phil Ward's original recipe from 2007
With the Oaxaca Old Fashioned there is one recipe that counts: Phil Ward's, from Death & Co in New York. Reposado tequila, LÆPOCA Mezcal, agave syrup, Angostura. Ratio and order have been unchanged since 2007. If you are looking for variations with mole bitters, pure mezcal or grapefruit zest, you will find them further down in the variations section.
Original · Phil Ward 2007
Oaxaca Old Fashioned
Reposado tequila and mezcal at a ratio of 3 to 1. Phil Ward's original recipe.
2 MinZubereitung
215 kcalPro Drink
TumblerGlas
Zutaten
4.5 clreposado tequila (El Tesoro, Olmeca Altos, Don Julio Reposado)
Add reposado tequila, LÆPOCA Mezcal, agave syrup and Angostura bitters to a mixing glass with ice.
Stir with a bar spoon for 20 to 30 seconds until the mixture is well chilled. Don't shake. An Old Fashioned is always stirred.
Strain into a tumbler over one large ice cube.
Squeeze the orange zest over the drink to release the essential oils.
If you like, flame the zest briefly with a match before squeezing. That intensifies the orange aromas and adds a spectacular bit of show. Finally drop the zest into the glass. Salud.
Since September 2023
Win a large professional cocktail set worth over €75 every twelve weeks
Was andere sagen
bewertet: Oaxaca Old Fashioned
Peter
vor 4 Monaten
★★★★★
Hab den Mayaciel als Tequila genutzt. Sehr zu empfehlen.
Schwierigkeit: Mittel
bewertet: Oaxaca Old Fashioned
Jay
vor 4 Monaten
★★★★★
Top! Sehr zu empfehlen
Schwierigkeit: Mittel
Plan your evening
How many Oaxaca Old Fashioneds do you need?
Enter the number of drinks and get the shopping list straight away. Tequila, mezcal, agave syrup, bitters and oranges for the zest.
LÆPOCA Mezcal EspadínFrom the 500 ml bottle · enough for about 33 drinks
—cl
Reposado tequilaEl Tesoro · Olmeca Altos · Don Julio Reposado
—cl
Reposado tequilaEl Tesoro · Olmeca Altos · Don Julio Reposado
—cl
Agave syrup1 tsp per drink · organic quality recommended
—cl
Angostura Bitters2 dashes per drink
—dashes
Oranges (for the zest)1 organic orange is enough for 4 zests · organic because of the peel
—oranges
Large ice cubes1 large cube per glass (4×4 cm) · silicone mould
—cubes
Einkaufszettel teilen
Four tips for the perfect Oaxaca Old Fashioned
The Oaxaca Old Fashioned is a purist drink. Four ingredients, stirred, done. That is exactly why the details decide the result. Four rules that separate a beginner's drink from a bar classic.
Rule 01
Stir, don't shake.
An Old Fashioned is stirred. Always. There is no discussion. Shaken versions turn cloudy and watery and lose the elegance that defines this drink. 20 to 30 seconds in a mixing glass with ice, then strain over one large ice cube in a tumbler. That is the whole technique.
Rule 02
The large ice cube is a must.
An Oaxaca Old Fashioned is sipped slowly, over 15 minutes or more. One large ice cube (4 by 4 cm) melts more slowly than many small ones, so the drink stays concentrated for longer. No large cubes? A silicone mould costs a few pounds online. A one-off investment for years of drinks.
Rule 03
Flaming the orange zest is not just show.
Flaming the orange zest is more than bartender theatre. When lit, the essential oils in the peel burn and settle on the drink as a veil of caramelised orange. On the first sip you breathe in these aromas before you taste the mezcal smoke. Important: use only organic oranges, as ordinary peel is treated with wax.
Rule 04
Don't overdo the mezcal.
Phil Ward's original recipe uses only 25 per cent mezcal. That is deliberate. With more mezcal the drink tips into pure smokiness and loses the elegance that the reposado tequila brings. If you experiment, keep 3 to 1 as your standard and only increase slightly with particularly mild mezcals. With wild-agave mezcals (Tepeztate, Tobalá) use rather less.
Which reposado tequila for the Oaxaca Old Fashioned?
Phil Ward originally used El Tesoro Reposado. The choice of base makes the difference. Reposado tequila has spent at least two months in oak and brings vanilla and gentle wood notes. Blanco tequila would be too sharp and would compete with the mezcal smoke. Four reposados that work well in an Oaxaca Old Fashioned.
The four reposado tequilas that fit
From Phil Ward's original tequila to the premium brand.
El Tesoro Reposado
Jalisco · the original
This is the tequila Phil Ward used in the original 2007 recipe. Complex, with pronounced agave notes and gentle oak ageing. If you want the original experience, this is the one to choose.
Olmeca Altos Reposado
Jalisco · Bar standard
A bar standard in many cocktail bars. A very good tequila at a fair price. A little sweeter than El Tesoro, with vanilla notes. Ideal as a way into the world of premium tequilas.
Don Julio Reposado
Jalisco · Premium classic
One of the best-known premium tequilas in the world. Clean, elegant, with caramel and vanilla. Very approachable, and it goes particularly well with mezcal smoke.
Patrón Reposado
Jalisco · soft and mild
The softest of the four options. Little oak character, plenty of agave freshness. It works with bolder mezcals that bring character of their own.
New York, 2007: how one bartender set off the mezcal boom
In the autumn of 2007 a bartender named Phil Ward mixed a new cocktail at Death & Co in New York's East Village. Death & Co was still a young bar, but already one of the most influential cocktail bars in the world. Ward put the drink on the menu.
At the time mezcal was almost unknown outside Mexico. Those who knew it thought of the notorious worm in the bottle and a rough substitute for tequila. In the United States mezcal was an outsider product that people drank as a shot at best. It had no place in high-end cocktails.
Ward was an advocate of what is known as the Mr. Potato Head theory. The idea: take a classic cocktail, swap out the main spirit and see what happens. He took the whiskey Old Fashioned and swapped the whiskey for reposado tequila, and the sugar for agave syrup. That suited the Mexican theme.
The stroke of genius came next. Instead of mixing the drink purely with tequila, Ward added a small amount of mezcal. A quarter of the spirit. Enough to give the drink character. Not enough to overwhelm it.
Phil Ward's idea in a nutshell: the mezcal should work as a seasoning, not as the main ingredient. Like black pepper on a steak.
The drink was an instant bestseller. First at Death & Co, then among New York's bartenders, then worldwide. Ward later moved on to his own bar, Mayahuel, where the Oaxaca Old Fashioned stayed on the menu. Within a few years bars in New York, London, Berlin and Tokyo had picked up the cocktail.
Today the Oaxaca Old Fashioned is seen as patient zero of the worldwide mezcal boom in high-end bars. Before it, mezcal was a niche product. After it, mezcal became the spirit of the moment. Many of today's mezcal brands, LÆPOCA included, owe a good part of their existence to this one idea from 2007.
The Mr. Potato Head theory worked. A classic whiskey Old Fashioned became a modern mezcal classic.
Why does mezcal as a seasoning work?
Phil Ward's real invention was not the recipe. It was the idea of using mezcal not as the main ingredient but as a modifier. As a seasoning. That insight has shaped the whole mezcal bar scene.
Pure mezcal cocktails are intense. The smoke dominates and the aromas are right there. That is wonderful if you love mezcal. For many guests it is too much.
Mezcal as a seasoning works differently. A small amount adds depth and complexity without taking over the drink. The mezcal hides. You only notice it on the second or third sip. Suddenly you understand why this Old Fashioned tastes different from any other.
The reposado tequila takes the lead. Its gentle vanilla and oak notes set the stage. The mezcal smoke joins in the background like a hint. The agave syrup links the two spirits, because they come from the same plant. The Angostura bitters add the final accent.
The result: a cocktail that starts like a classic Old Fashioned and ends with a hint of campfire. That balance is exactly what made Ward's drink a modern classic.
Tip: for more chocolate depth, use mole bitters instead of Angostura. Bittermens Xocolatl Mole Bitters are standard for this version in many cocktail bars and are easy to find online.
Six variations of the Mezcal Old Fashioned
Phil Ward's original recipe is the standard, but bartenders have been experimenting with variations for well over a decade. Different bitters, different citrus zests, different ratios of spirits. Six versions you will find in modern bars.
Mole bitters version
Chocolate depth · Bartender's choice
Bittermens Xocolatl Mole Bitters go into the glass instead of Angostura. They add chocolate and spice notes that, together with the mezcal smoke, give an almost dessert-like depth. A popular variation in mezcal bars.
Pure Mezcal Old Fashioned
Mezcal only · for enthusiasts
No tequila at all. 6 cl LÆPOCA Mezcal, 1 tsp agave syrup, 2 dashes Angostura. More intense, smokier, more uncompromising. Not for your first Oaxaca Old Fashioned, but all the better for your twentieth.
Grapefruit Old Fashioned
Grapefruit instead of orange
A grapefruit zest instead of orange zest. The bitter notes of grapefruit go even better with the mezcal smoke than the sweeter orange notes.
Naked and Famous
Mezcal IBA classic · 2011
Joaquín Simó, who worked alongside Phil Ward, created this cocktail at Death & Co in 2011. Four equal parts mezcal, Yellow Chartreuse, Aperol and lime juice. Shaken rather than stirred. An official IBA cocktail since 2020. Related to the Oaxaca Old Fashioned, but with a completely different profile.
Smoked Oaxaca Old Fashioned
With a smoke gun · modern bar
The whole glass is filled with hickory or cherry-wood smoke before serving. A smoke gun or a smoking chip on a coaster is all you need. The effect: double smoke, from outside and inside. A showpiece for house parties.
Mezcal Manhattan
+ vermouth · Bar classic
A slightly different cocktail, but the same family. 6 cl mezcal, 3 cl red vermouth, 2 dashes Angostura. A cocktail cherry to garnish. Like the Oaxaca Old Fashioned a stirred drink, but with vermouth instead of agave syrup. For Manhattan fans who want to discover mezcal.
Frequently asked questions about the Oaxaca Old Fashioned
What is an Oaxaca Old Fashioned?
The Oaxaca Old Fashioned is a modern cocktail classic from 2007, created by Phil Ward at Death & Co in New York. It is made with 4.5 cl reposado tequila, 1.5 cl mezcal, 1 tsp agave syrup and 2 dashes of Angostura bitters. It is stirred and served over one large ice cube in a tumbler, garnished with orange zest. The name comes from the Mexican state of Oaxaca, where mezcal is made.
Why is the cocktail called Oaxaca Old Fashioned?
Oaxaca is the Mexican state where most mezcal is produced. The vast majority of the world's mezcal comes from Oaxaca, above all from the region around Santiago Matatlán. Phil Ward chose the name as a tribute to the origin of the mezcal that gives his drink its defining character. Oaxaca, by the way, is pronounced “wah-HAH-kah”.
How do you pronounce Oaxaca?
“Wah-HAH-kah”. In Mexican Spanish the X here is pronounced like a breathy H. Many English speakers say “oh-AX-a-ca”, which is wrong. If you want to order the cocktail at a bar, ask for a wah-HAH-kah Old Fashioned. Any Mexican will understand you.
Which tequila works in an Oaxaca Old Fashioned?
Reposado tequila is a must. Blanco tequila would be too sharp and would compete with the mezcal smoke. Añejo tequila (aged 1 to 3 years in cask) would be too sweet and woody. Reposado spends at least 2 months in oak and brings a gentle vanilla that suits the mezcal. Phil Ward's original uses El Tesoro Reposado. Olmeca Altos and Don Julio Reposado are also very good options.
Can I replace Angostura with mole bitters?
Yes, and many bartenders even recommend it. Bittermens Xocolatl Mole Bitters add chocolate and spice notes that, together with the mezcal smoke, give an almost dessert-like depth. They are easy to find online, and one bottle is enough for hundreds of drinks.
Why not shake the drink?
An Old Fashioned is stirred, never shaken. That applies to every Old Fashioned, whether made with whiskey, bourbon or mezcal. Shaking creates air bubbles, turns the drink cloudy and loses the silky texture that defines it. The drink also contains only clear ingredients, with no fruit juice or egg white. Cocktails like that are always stirred. 20 to 30 seconds in a mixing glass with ice is enough.
What is the difference from a whiskey Old Fashioned?
The whiskey Old Fashioned is the original. Bourbon or rye whiskey, sugar, Angostura, orange zest. A very old cocktail, documented since the 19th century. The Oaxaca Old Fashioned is Phil Ward's Mexican version. Reposado tequila instead of whiskey, mezcal as a seasoning, agave syrup instead of sugar. Both have the same structure but completely different aromas. The whiskey Old Fashioned tastes of vanilla and caramel. The Oaxaca Old Fashioned of agave and campfire.
A 500 ml bottle of LÆPOCA Mezcal Espadín makes around 33 Oaxaca Old Fashioneds. Artesanal, from Santiago Matatlán, Oaxaca. Add a bottle of reposado tequila, agave syrup, Angostura and a few organic oranges. Easily enough for your next house party.